pa judge of the superior court candidates 2023

He held the rank of U.S. Army captain when he retired from the military in 2016. Spotlight PA is an independent, nonpartisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with PennLive/The Patriot-News, TribLIVE/Pittsburgh Tribune-Review and WITF Public Media. By tradition, appointed interim judges of the supreme court, superior court, or court of appeals do not go on to run for permanent seats. Read Smails answers to the PBA questionnaire here. Recent rulings include a 2022 decision that found the state's mail voting law unconstitutional a decision later overruled by the state Supreme Court and a February opinion that found the. Lane first ran for Superior Court in 2021. Recent rulings include a 2022 decision that found the states mail voting law unconstitutional a decision later overruled by the state Supreme Court and a February opinion that found the states education funding system violated the rights of parents and students in poorer districts. Lebanon who works in commercial litigation. Judge of the Superior Court of Pennsylvania: D: Highly Recommended: The bar ranks judicial candidates as highly recommended, recommended or not recommended based on the candidates judicial record and interviews with a judicial evaluation commission. She also was a prosecutor in Franklin and Venango Counties, and was a contract specialist for the Department of Defense. Prior to his election to the court in 2017, Wolf ran a legal practice based in Cherry Hill, N.J., that focused on employment law and civil rights. Dugan attended law school between two stints in the Army first as an enlisted airborne infantryman in the 1980s and then as a civil affairs noncommissioned officer in Iraq and a judge advocate officer in Afghanistan. Currently, Democrats have a 4-2 advantage on the seven-member state Supreme Court so a Republican winning Baers seat would not change the balance of power. On its website, the party points to rulings Smail made in 2020 that upheld essential anti-fraud requirements for casting a mail-in ballot.. A Cumberland County resident and Widener University law school graduate, Martin is the former parliamentarian of the state Senate and is endorsed by the state Republican Party in the primary race for Commonwealth Court. He ordered the board to throw out 204 provisional ballots those that are cast when a persons registration cannot be immediately verified it wanted to count. In 2010, Dugan co-founded Philadelphias Veterans Court, which handles cases in which current or former military members are charged with nonviolent misdemeanors. She also spent several years as legal counsel for Democratic state Sen. Anthony Williams before being elected to the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas in 2013. He received his law degree from Duquesne University. Their rulings can be appealed to the state Supreme Court, Pennsylvanias court of last resort. The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Wolf as recommended, saying that his writing is clear and concise, and noting that he has a history of public service. The trial court hears appeals for civil, criminal and family matters. Wolf spent years in the U.S. Army Reserve, serving as an officer from 2003 to 2020 and deploying to Afghanistan and Iraq. On Tuesday, Montgomery County Court President Judge Carolyn Carluccio announced she would seek the seat left open by the September death of Supreme Court Justice Max Baer. Commonwealth Court presides over civil actions brought by and against the Pennsylvania state government and hears appeals primarily in cases involving state departments and local governments. Prince has sued the city of Harrisburg to block the enforcement of old gun laws, and sued the state and federal governments to block bans on bump stocks and partial firearm frames that lack identifying information, which opponents have labeled ghost guns.. It is impossible to know everyones personal background from a 1-minute interaction, he said. See Pa.R.Crim.P. Heres why experts are worried. . The president judge of the court is selected through a vote by members of the Superior Court and serves a five-year term. The panels main role is to review lower courts verdicts. . Pa. could become a national outlier in how it elects appellate judges. There are a few key differences between a judicial election and other political elections in the commonwealth, however. The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Lanehighly recommended, saying that her writing is well-reasoned, clear and concise.. He has the endorsement of a handful of conservative rank-and-file GOP lawmakers, county sheriffs, and gun rights groups, including Firearms Owners Against Crime. In his PBA questionnaire, he noted that his clients included many women involved in pregnancy discrimination, hostile work environment, and sexual harassment cases. Pennsylvanias two intermediate appellate courts have the power to affirm or reverse decisions made in lower courts. Ritter v. . The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Neft as recommended, writing that peers viewed him as hard working, honest and committed to equal justice, fairness and impartiality in the judicial system.. ), >>Register to vote, change your registration, request a mail ballot, and read more guides at spotlightpa.org/elections. Currently a judge on the state Superior Court, where she's served since 2017, McLaughlin is formerly a Philadelphia Common Pleas judge. In her questionnaire for the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Beck said that during her time as a clerk on Superior Court she drafted memoranda and published opinions on nearly 500 decisions. Pennsylvania Supreme Court: Elections: 2023 2022 2021 2020 . The material on this website is for general education and its posting does not imply that PMC supports or opposes any candidate. The court repudiated the independent state legislature theory, which could have transformed elections for Congress and president. In February, Prince attended a Susquehanna County Republicans event and posed for a group photo that included Frank Scavo, a former Republican legislative candidate who was sentenced to 60 days in prison for participating in the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol. She has been a federal prosecutor in Delaware and became Montgomery Countys first female chief public defender in January 2002. They also want jurists who will bring experience, temperament and impartiality to our Commonwealths highest court.. Primary voters will pick two candidates from their own party; the two Democrats and the two Republicans with the most votes will move on to the November general election. . If you republish the piece online, please include all the hyperlinks from the original piece. Pennsylvania is one of nine states that has closed primaries, which prevent third-party and unaffiliated voters from participating in partisan elections. First appointed to the court in 2007 by former Democratic Gov. HARRISBURG When voters go to the polls or fill out their mail ballots for Pennsylvania's May 16 primary election, they'll see a slew of local candidates with a lot of direct power over their daily lives. Not all voters will be able to participate in the upcoming judicial primaries, which will be held May 16. That year, Smail ruled against the Westmoreland County Board of Elections in a case brought by a Republican candidate for state Senate in an extremely close race. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. CONCURRING OPINION BY JUDGE McCULLOUGH FILED: June 27, 2023 Given that the Third Circuit Court of Appeals' decision in Migliori v. Cohen, 36 F.4th 153 (3d Cir. Ed Rendell, Dugan was then elected to the court in 2009 and retained in 2015. Lane first ran for Superior Court in 2021. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. Pennsylvania is one of nine states that has closed primaries, which prevent third-party and unaffiliated voters from participating in partisan elections. Commonwealth Court presides over civil actions brought by and against the Pennsylvania state government and hears appeals primarily in cases involving state departments and local governments. and won a seat on Superior Court in 2017. . The president judge of the court is selected through a vote by members of the Superior Court and serves a five-year term. Its partisan makeup is currently split, with seven Democrats and seven Republicans. Before that, he was a private practice attorney who ran unsuccessfully for numerous county offices. All judges who preside over the court are veterans. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 4/4/2023), Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (updated 7/1/2023). A graduate of Boston University School of Law, Neft has predominantly spent his career in private practice. The two intermediate appellate courts serve distinct roles in the commonwealths legal system. Read Becks answers to the PBA questionnaire here. PA Supreme Court primary candidates, from left, clockwise: Deborah Kunselman; Daniel McCaffery; Patricia McCullough; Carolyn Carluccio. She ran for Superior Court in 2021 but was defeated in the primary by Timika Lane. I have confidence voters will once again see that a single organizational endorsement is not the full measure of a candidate, and that they will base their decision on the totality of actual experience, especially in the courtroom, Prince said. On its website, the party points to rulings Smail made in 2020 that upheld essential anti-fraud requirements for casting a mail-in ballot.. Pennsylvania is one of a handful of states that elect judges in partisan contests, meaning candidates run under the banner of a political party, collect endorsements, and raise money. Recent rulings include a 2022 decision that found the state's mail voting law unconstitutional a decision later overruled by the state Supreme Court and a February opinion that found the state's education funding system violated the rights of parents and students in poorer districts. Please do not republish the photographs that accompany this piece without asking for permission. Dugans peers on the court elected him president judge in 2019. The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Neft as recommended, writing that peers viewed him as hard working, honest and committed to equal justice, fairness and impartiality in the judicial system.. Smail ruled that the board of elections did not conduct due diligence in accepting those 204 votes without further substantiating evidence that they hadnt voted twice. That year, Smail ruled against the Westmoreland County Board of Elections in a case brought by a Republican candidate for state Senate in an extremely close race. Judges serve initial 10-year terms, then face nonpartisan retention votes, which usually succeed. The two intermediate appellate courts serve distinct roles in the commonwealths legal system. The candidates for this general election are Eric J. Mikovch, Leigh Ann Orton, and Peter J. Sala. Candidates for statewide office were endorsed at a meeting of the Republican State Committee in early February. April 18, 2023 at 04:18 PM 6 minute read Judges By ALM Staff | April 18, 2023 at 04:18 PM Candidate: Maria C. Battista Court: Superior Court Party: Republican Pennsylvania Bar. The person who wins the open seat on Commonwealth Court could help shape Pennsylvanias laws on everything from elections to firearms, while the two candidates who win seats on Superior Court could decide the outcomes of high-profile criminal cases. Current non-senior judges are 5 Republicans and 3 Democrats. Pennsylvania is one of a handful of states that elect judges in partisan contests, meaning candidates run under the banner of a political party, collect endorsements, and raise money. Spotlight PA has noted these rankings, as well as other key details, in its profiles of the candidates: The nine-member Commonwealth Court is the first stop for many high-profile cases. Wolf is a judge on the Philadelphia Municipal Court, where he has served since 2018. Carluccio was the countys chief deputy solicitor before being elected a county judge. Primary voters will pick two candidates from their own party; the two Democrats and the two Republicans with the most votes will move on to the November general election. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Read Lanes answers to the PBA questionnaire here. Wolf is a judge on the Philadelphia Municipal Court, where he has served since 2018. Lane has served as a Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas judge since 2014. A Clarion County resident who holds a law degree from Ohio Northern University, Battista previously served as assistant general counsel for the departments of Health and State under former Govs. Smail ruled that the board of elections did not conduct due diligence in accepting those 204 votes without further substantiating evidence that they hadnt voted twice. The login page will open in a new tab. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. Judge Daniel McCaffery won the Democratic nomination while Judge Carolyn Carluccio won the Republican primary. Prince is not recommended by the state bar association, which found that he lacks the depth and breadth of experience and preparation necessary to take on the commanding role of judge on the Commonwealth Court.. It reviews most of the civil and criminal cases that are appealed from the courts of common pleas in the state's 67 counties. While the Court is loath to impose the consequences of a failure of the Board onto an innocent electorate the court must apply the provisions of the Elections Code consistently and as written by our legislature, Smail wrote in the 12-page decision. Angela Bassett, Mel Brooks to receive honorary Oscars, Butler family saved dog while in St. Louis, Trying to save his life, lawyers for Pittsburgh synagogue gunman argue he is mentally ill, Fourth defendant sentenced to prison in 2020 drug-related slaying of classmate, Response to fiery Ohio derailment frustrated by poor communication and incomplete information, Ex-chief public defender to run for Pennsylvania attorney general, Pennsylvania lawmakers eye liberalization of medical marijuana rules, Probe blames Luzerne Countys November ballot paper shortage on inexperience, poor training, Interstate 95 reopens less than two weeks after deadly collapse in Philadelphia, Tax credits for Pa. families worth billions of dollars are on the table this budget season, Biden says the U.S. and NATO had no involvement in the Wagner group insurrection in Russia, John Goodenough, a Nobel Prize-winning co-creator of the revolutionary lithium battery, dies at 100, High-speed internet is a necessity, President Biden says, pledging all US will have access by 2030, The next big advance in cancer treatment could be a vaccine, Nashville, Bristol working to give NASCAR a historic racing option in Music City, Birth Announcements, Anniversaries, Weddings, Graduations & More, Examples of In Memoriams, Birthday Tributes & More, Butler County Tourism & Convention Bureau. There is one seat open on Commonwealth Court this year, and both parties primaries have multiple candidates vying for the nomination. Prince has sued Harrisburg to block the enforcement of old gun laws, and sued the state and federal governments to block bans on bump stocks and partial firearm frames that lack identifying information, which opponents have labeled ghost guns.. Read Nefts answers to the PBA questionnaire here. There are two open seats on Superior Court this year. Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license. He has the endorsement of a handful of conservative rank-and-file GOP lawmakers, county sheriffs and gun rights groups, including Firearms Owners Against Crime. It is impossible to know everyones personal background from a 1-minute interaction, he said. A Cumberland County resident and Widener University law school graduate, Martin is the former parliamentarian of the state Senate and is endorsed by the state Republican Party in the primary race for Commonwealth Court. . The terms of four Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court and two Pennsylvania Superior Court judges expired on January 3, 2022. While the Court is loath to impose the consequences of a failure of the Board onto an innocent electorate the court must apply the provisions of the Elections Code consistently and as written by our legislature, Smail wrote in the 12-page decision. Site last updated: Tuesday, June 27, 2023, Box truck crashes into McBride Station in Penn Township, In a forward-heavy NHL draft class, teams looking for defensemen have options topped by Reinbacher, Original SRU mascot attends alumni week, reunites with costume made by his mother. There are a few key differences between a judicial election and other political elections in the commonwealth, however. She is endorsed by the state Republican Party. Pa. primary election 2023: Supreme Court candidates with party backing show fundraising advantage The PA Supreme Court candidates running in the 2023 primary election have raised $365,000 from wealthy donors, their own bank accounts, and more. Lebanon who works in commercial litigation. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court is the state's court of last resort and has seven judgeships. The winners will face off in November. "I sent letters out to every affinity bar president last week asking them to state whether or not they have a pipeline for judicial candidates from their bars," New Jersey State Bar President . In his PBA questionnaire, he noted that his clients included many women involved in pregnancy discrimination, hostile work environment and sexual harassment cases. Lebanon Democratic Party from 2016 to 2020, when he resigned to run for Superior Court. Dugan attended law school between two stints in the U.S. Army first as an enlisted airborne infantryman in the 1980s and then as a civil affairs noncommissioned officer in Iraq and a judge advocate officer in Afghanistan. Tom Ridge and Tom Corbett, as an attorney for the U.S. Navy, and as a law clerk for a Lancaster County judge. 80% of consumers turn to directories with reviews to find a local business. five judges on the court were elected in partisan elections as Democrats, one judge was elected as a Republican, and one judge was appointed by a Democratic governor. Beck has also worked at KidsVoice, a nonprofit agency that advocates for children in the child welfare system in Allegheny Countys Juvenile Court. StateCollege.com provides local news, entertainment, and information for State College, PA. We offer the latest breaking news and videos straight from the Centre County region in Central PA. 220 Regent Court, Suite B, State College, PA 16801, Copyright 2000 document.getElementById('copyright').appendChild(document.createTextNode(new Date().getFullYear())) | StateCollege.com | All Rights Reserved | State College, PA Centre County Central Pennsylvania Home of Penn State University. The person who wins the open seat on Commonwealth Court could help shape Pennsylvanias laws on everything from elections to firearms, while the two candidates who win seats on Superior Court could decide the outcomes of high-profile criminal cases. The people on the lost sub could afforded to pay$250,000 for that stupid trip. Judges serve initial 10-year terms, then face a nonpartisan retention vote, which usually succeeds. Tom Ridge and Tom Corbett, as an attorney for the U.S. Navy, and as a law clerk for a Lancaster County judge. Judges on both courts are often top candidates to fill openings on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Primary voters will pick two candidates from their own party; the two Democrats and the two Republicans with the most votes will move on to the November general election. Q&A. A Clarion County resident who holds a law degree from Ohio Northern University, Battista previously served as assistant general counsel for the departments of Health and State under former Govs. Pennsylvanians want their judges to read and apply the law, Carluccio, a Republican, said in a statement. Dugans peers on the court elected him president judge in 2019. The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Lanehighly recommended, saying that her writing is well-reasoned, clear and concise.. Superior Court handles criminal, family, and civil cases that are appealed by county Courts of Common Pleas. Smail has been a Westmoreland County Common Pleas judge since former Republican Gov. Please do not edit the piece other than making minor changes to adhere to your publications preferred style guide. He held the rank of U.S. Army captain when he retired from the military in 2016. ABOUTJudicial Vote 2023. Read Lanes answers to the PBA questionnaire here. He is endorsed by the state Republican Party. Superior Court handles criminal, family, and civil cases that are appealed by county Courts of Common Pleas. A Berks County lawyer and Widener University law school graduate, Prince runs a firm that specializes in gun-related litigation. The bar rated Smail recommended, based on his extensive background, legal ability and temperament.. PA Commonwealth Court is one of two statewide intermediate appellate courts and decides most cases in three-judge panels in Philadelphia, Harrisburg, and Pittsburg. Spotlight PA is funded by foundationsand readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results. Tom Ridge and Tom Corbett, as an attorney for the Navy, and as a law clerk for a Lancaster County judge. Elections Pa. primary election 2023: How to vote, where to vote, and everything you need to know for May 16 . 00:56 Meet Jill Beck A Champion of Fairness and Justice for ALL Pennsylvanians (e spaol) Jill Beck has dedicated her career to ensuring that all Pennsylvanians have access to justice. Neft is an attorney based in Mount Lebanon who works in commercial litigation. The entrance to the Pennsylvania Judicial Center. Now we have to millions to rescue them. She then spent a year working primarily in private practice family law before taking a job as an assistant public defender in Philadelphia from 2004 to 2009. She has since left that job to run for office, according to the Courier-Express, and now works as vice president of state and federal contracting for The Judge Group, a Wayne-based consulting firm. Before joining the chamber, she served as a staffer and then an attorney for former GOP Govs. In February, Prince attended a Susquehanna County Republicans event and posed for a group photo that included Frank Scavo, a former Republican legislative candidate who was sentenced to 60 days in prison for participating in the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol. Beck has also worked at KidsVoice, a nonprofit agency that advocates for children in the child welfare system in Allegheny Countys Juvenile Court. Published: Nov. 29, 2022, 5:29 p.m. By J.D. As of March 23, the Pennsylvania Bar Association had not assigned Dugan a rating. She now hopes to serve on the Pennsylvania Superior Court to continue her tireless fight for fairness in our judicial system. BEFORE: HONORABLE RENE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge HONORABLE PATRICIA A. McCULLOUGH, Judge . It is impossible to know everyones personal background from a one-minute interaction, he said. Prospective judges cant directly ask for donations, though their campaign committees can. McCaffery is the brother of former state Supreme Court Justice Seamus McCaffery, who retired in 2014 after being suspended for his role in a scandal involving the swapping of pornographic emails with employees in the state attorney generals office. North Carolina Republicans had asked the court to leave state legislatures virtually unchecked by their state courts when dealing with federal elections. while they can vote for up to two Superior Court candidates since there are two vacant seats. Welcome to your voters' guide to Pennsylvania's 2023 primary election. She is endorsed by the state Republican Party. 2023 Elections for Appellate Court Judges. Beck is a Pittsburgh-based attorney who works in commercial litigation. The trial court hears appeals for civil, criminal and family matters. After resigning his commission in 2020, he enlisted in the Pennsylvania Army National Guard. As the secretary-parliamentarian, Martin advised the chambers presiding officer on how to run floor proceedings in accordance with the state constitution, law and chamber rules. Pennsylvanians deserve a justice who will always protect, obey and defend the constitution.. Sign up for our free newsletters. https://gettysburgconnection.org/author/spotlight_pa/, Copyright 2023 gettysburgconnection.org. In her questionnaire for the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Beck said that during her time as a clerk on Superior Court she drafted memoranda and published opinions on nearly 500 decisions. The Pennsylvania Bar Association rated Wolf as recommended, saying that his writing is clear and concise, and noting that he has a history of public service. She won the primary, beating Beck, but lost by 7 percentage points to Republican challenger Megan Sullivan. Recent rulings include a 2022 decision that found the states mail voting law unconstitutional a decision later overruled by the state Supreme Court and a February opinion that found the states education funding system violated the rights of parents and students in poorer districts. SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA ACBA JUDICIARY COMMITTEE RATING CANDIDATE NAME Jill Lipman Beck Highly Recommended The Pa. Bar Association rated candidates for the PA Superior Court. (For such permissions requests or any other questions please contact us: admin@gettysburgconnection.org. There is one seat open on Commonwealth Court this year, and both parties primaries have multiple candidates vying for the nomination. The 15-member Superior Court handles all nongovernment-related criminal and civil cases. The panel's main role is to review lower courts' verdicts. All judges who preside over the court are veterans. First appointed to the court in 2007 by former Democratic Gov. Commonwealth Court presides over civil actions brought by and against the Pennsylvania state government and hears appeals primarily in cases involving state departments and local governments. Prince is not recommended by the state bar association, which found that he lacks the depth and breadth of experience and preparation necessary to take on the commanding role of judge on the Commonwealth Court.. She is endorsed by the state Republican Party. Subscribe to read the full article and support our local, independent news organization. Wolf spent years in the Army Reserve, serving as an officer from 2003 to 2020 and deploying to Afghanistan and Iraq. In an email, Prince said he disagreed with his rating and pointed to the success of candidates who didnt have the groups blessing. Neft served as a committee member for the Mt. Beck has also worked at KidsVoice, a nonprofit agency that advocates for children in the child welfare system in Allegheny Countys Juvenile Court. One seat will be open. Lane has served as a Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas judge since 2014. By browsing this site, we may share your information with our social media partners in accordance with our, More Local Journalism to Love - $1 for 3 months Expires 6/30/23, a scandal involving the swapping of pornographic emails. There is one seat open on Commonwealth Court this year, and both parties primaries have multiple candidates vying for the nomination. Judge Deborah Kunselman, a Beaver County Democrat, said Wednesday that she will seek the seat formerly held by Justice Max Baer, who died in September. Prospective judges cant directly ask for donations, though their campaign committees can. Jill represented up to 225 children at a given time before magisterial district judges, the Court of Common Pleas, and the Pennsylvania Superior Court. Neft served as a committee member for the Mt. McCaffery announced his candidacy earlier this month. Ratings from the Pennsylvania Bar Association can be similarly important. . GOP state Supreme Court candidate Patricia McCullough was also in the photo. In an email, Prince said he disagreed with his rating and pointed to the success of candidates who didnt have the groups blessing. Superior Court candidate Jill Beck. Judges on both courts are often top candidates to fill openings on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA The Pa. Bar Association rated candidates for the PA Supreme Court. Prince is not recommended by the state bar association, which found that he lacks the depth and breadth of experience and preparation necessary to take on the commanding role of judge on the Commonwealth Court.. By signing the book, the voters instead indicated they cast a ballot using a voting machine. Before joining the chamber, she served as a staffer and then an attorney for former GOP Govs. Spotlight PA is funded by foundations and readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results. This story is shared with you as a digital media exclusive. Notable recent decisions include a 2019 opinion tossing out rapper Meek Millss conviction on drug and gun charges. Smail has been a Westmoreland County Common Pleas judge since former Republican Gov. While the Court is loath to impose the consequences of a failure of the Board onto an innocent electorate the court must apply the provisions of the Elections Code consistently and as written by our legislature, Smail wrote in the 12-page decision.

Trinity Church Evening Service, Hoi4 Lend Lease Not Working, Greenwich Village Newspaper, For Rent By Owner Under $700, Stoneblock 2 Server Files, Barstool Merchapoolza, How Much Did Kramer Make From Seinfeld, 1st Dui In California Penalties,